Live
Challenger Says Espaillat 'Ignored' ICE-Detained Student
16D AGOUSU.S. REPRESENTATIVE ADRIANO ESPAILLATNY-13 DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY

Challenger Says Espaillat 'Ignored' ICE-Detained Student

What's the gist?

Primary challenger Darializa Avila Chevalier criticizes Rep. Adriano Espaillat for not meeting with Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil's family during his ICE detention, raising questions about Espaillat's campaign donors and responsiveness to constituents.

Context

Espaillat, the 71-year-old "dean of Dominican elected officials," faces his toughest primary challenge in nine years from DSA organizer Avila Chevalier, who recently received Mayor Mamdani's endorsement and outraised the incumbent last quarter - with the help of a pro-Palestinian SuperPAC. Questions were also raised in the recent debate about ICE contractors contributing to Espaillat's campaign. He is the first formerly undocumented person to be elected to Congress.

Positive takes

Proven Track Record. Espaillat argues he has consistently fought ICE and Trump policies throughout his congressional tenure, demonstrating long-term commitment to immigrant rights.
Fighting Corporate Influence. The congressman maintains he's accountable only to his constituents, not donors, despite receiving contributions from various sources including PACs.
Experienced Leadership. As a veteran representative with nearly a decade in Congress, Espaillat brings institutional knowledge and established relationships to advocate for the district.

Negative takes

Failed Constituent Services. Critics argue Espaillat's lack of outreach to Khalil's family during detention shows he's out of touch with his community's needs and struggles.
AIPAC Over People. Opponents claim the congressman prioritizes outside political interests over his own constituents, pointing to substantial PAC contributions including from AIPAC.
Reactive Not Proactive. Khalil states Espillat only reached out nearly a year after detention, and only after being publicly challenged, suggesting opportunistic rather than genuine concern.
News sources
  1. 01
    The New York Times Staff · The New York Times · June 2, 2026
  2. 02
  3. 03
Social takes
  1. 01
    sallygold · Twitter · Positive take
  2. 02
    sallygold · Twitter · Positive take
  3. 03
    @mahmoudkhalel · Twitter · Negative take
  4. 04
    @mahmoudkhalel · Twitter · Negative take
Who are you leaning toward in this race?Pick a candidate to see where New Yorkers stand