Salazar Pushes Anti-Shackling Bill After Brooklyn Courtroom Birth

Positive takes

Closing Critical Loopholes. Salazar's bill addresses gaps in existing law that leave pregnant people vulnerable to degrading treatment in police custody and courtrooms.

Protecting Basic Dignity. The legislation ensures pregnant women receive humane treatment during one of life's most vulnerable moments, preventing traumatic experiences like the Brooklyn courtroom birth.

Evidence-Based Reform. With most states having similar protections and documented cases of abuse, New York needs comprehensive anti-shackling laws that actually cover all custody settings.

Negative takes

Enforcement Questions. Critics worry that even with new laws, officers may continue shackling pregnant women since existing prison protections are often ignored by guards and officials.

Limited Impact Concerns. Some argue the bill won't prevent future incidents if law enforcement isn't properly trained on anti-shackling laws or held accountable for violations.

Timing and Priorities. With the legislative session ending in June, skeptics question whether lawmakers will prioritize this bill over other pressing criminal justice reforms.