Principled Leadership. Valdez demonstrated moral courage by taking an early, clear stance on Gaza when it wasn't politically convenient, showing she won't wait for public opinion to shift.
117D AGOSTATEASSEMBLYMEMBER CLAIRE VALDEZ
Palestinian PAC endorses Mamdani-backed Claire Valdez for Congress
What's the gist?
The newly formed pro-Palestinian PAL PAC endorsed Assembly Member Claire Valdez for Congress, highlighting her staunch advocacy for Gaza and criticism of Israel as central to her campaign for Nydia Velázquez's seat.
Context
Valdez has been an outspoken critic of Israel since October 2023, calling for ceasefire immediately after Hamas attacks. She was arrested protesting outside senators' offices and co-sponsored legislation targeting pro-Israel charities.
Positive takes
Consistent Advocacy. Her arrest at protests and legislative work on the Not on Our Dime bill shows she backs up her words with concrete action on Palestinian rights.
Progressive Momentum. The endorsement from PAL PAC, along with support from DSA and Justice Democrats, positions her as a strong voice for underrepresented communities in Congress.
Negative takes
Divisive Positioning. Critics argue her unequivocal pro-Palestinian stance and genocide accusations against Israel could alienate moderate voters and Jewish constituents in her diverse district.
Questionable Associations. Being introduced by a detained protest organizer and accepting endorsements from groups that support boycotting Israel raises concerns about extremist connections.
Limited Differentiation. Since her main opponent Antonio Reynoso holds similar positions on Palestine, the endorsement may not provide the competitive advantage her campaign needs.
— by VoiceWhat's Voice? Read this.
How is Claire Valdez doing in this moment?
Rate and see what New Yorkers think