Historic and Qualified. Bonsignore's 31 years of FDNY service, including leading EMS through COVID and responding on 9/11, makes her more qualified than most — Musk's criticism is uninformed.
186D AGOLOCALNYC MAYOR ZOHRAN MAMDANICRIME & SAFETY
Elon Musk Says "People Will Die" Over Mamdani's FDNY Pick — Mayor Fires Back Defending 9/11 First Responder
What's the gist?
Elon Musk attacked Mayor Zohran Mamdani for appointing Lillian Bonsignore as FDNY Commissioner, claiming "people will die" because she lacks firefighting experience. Mamdani fired back, pointing out Bonsignore is a 31-year FDNY veteran, 9/11 first responder, and COVID-era EMS chief who led the division handling 70% of all FDNY calls. Bonsignore is the first openly gay person and second woman to hold the position.
Context
Mamdani appointed Lillian Bonsignore, a 31-year veteran who led EMS through COVID and responded on 9/11, as FDNY Commissioner on January 1, 2026. Musk attacked the choice on X, claiming "people will die" due to her lack of firefighting experience. Mamdani defended her, noting EMS handles 70% of FDNY calls. She is the first openly LGBTQ+ person to hold the role.
Positive takes
Mamdani Stands His Ground. The new mayor isn't backing down from the world's richest man — a sign he'll prioritize New Yorkers over billionaire pressure campaigns.
Breaking Barriers. The first openly gay FDNY Commissioner is a milestone for representation in city government and the fire service.
Negative takes
Valid Safety Concern. Critics argue fire operations require specialized experience — running EMS is fundamentally different from commanding firefighters at a blaze.
Political Appointment. Some see this as Mamdani prioritizing identity over experience, valuing being "first" over selecting the most qualified firefighting leader.
Picking Fights Already. Musk may be wrong, but Mamdani's combative response to every critic suggests a mayor more interested in Twitter feuds than governing.
— by VoiceWhat's Voice? Read this.
News sources
- 01
- 02
- 03
- 04
How is Zohran Mamdani doing in this moment?
Rate and see what New Yorkers think