Standing Against Tokenism. Hanif's anger reflects frustration with Muslims being used to legitimize anti-Palestinian positions and normalize support for Israeli policies.
48D AGOLOCALNYC COUNCIL MEMBER SHAHANA HANIFISRAEL
Hanif Clashes Online With Muslims Protesting For Israel
What's the gist?
Brooklyn Councilwoman Shahana Hanif clashed with two Muslim women who were protesting for Israel. She wrote in an X post: "may allah condemn you to jahannam," the Islamic concept of hell.
Context
The protest targeted mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and was organized by EndJewHatred. Organizer Anila Ali called Mamdani's supporters "Islamist" and said they hijacked Islam for anti-Jewish purposes. Both Hanif and Mandani ran their campaigns with pro-Palestine platforms.
Positive takes
Religious Authenticity. Her response challenges what she sees as Muslims abandoning solidarity with Palestinians to gain acceptance from mainstream political establishments.
Anti-Colonial Solidarity. Supporters view her reaction as defending principled opposition to what they consider Israeli occupation and ethnic cleansing.
Negative takes
Dangerous Religious Rhetoric. Using Islamic concepts of damnation against fellow Muslims crosses ethical lines and weaponizes faith for political attacks.
Silencing Muslim Voices. Condemning Muslims who support Israel undermines the diversity of opinion within Muslim communities and promotes religious orthodoxy.
Divisive Leadership. Elected officials should build bridges between communities, not use inflammatory language that deepens interfaith tensions and alienates constituents.
— by VoiceWhat's Voice? Read this.
News sources
- 01
Caitlin McCormack · AOL.com · June 4, 2026
- 02
NY Post Staff · NY Post · May 26, 2026
Social takes
- 01
ShahanafromBK · Twitter · Negative take
How is Shahana Hanif doing in this moment?
Rate and see what New Yorkers think